Spurgeon v. Osteen (Wanna Guess Who Wins?)
Michael Spencer, the Internet Monk, posts a piece comparing the first sermon Spurgeon preached in the Metropolitan Tabernacle with the first sermon Joel Osteen preached in the Compaq Church.
Spurgeon and Osteen: The Tale of Inaugural Sermons
I’m guessing that my readers already know how this confrontation turns out…
If the preaching of the gospel has become unpopular, and if people won’t stand for the truth of Christ, and if to scratch whatever ecclesiastical itch it is that we feel the need to scratch, we must water the message down to happy-talk pablum and vacuous dream-talk…then let’s pack it in, shall we?
“I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ, for it is the power of God unto salvation to all who believe…” Even if some “preachers” are…





Essential Evangelical Parallel Bible
Marco Polo: From Venice to Xanadu (Vintage)
The Glory Game: How the 1958 NFL Championship Changed Football Forever
This phrase comes from the 1978 "Jonestown massacre" in which most members of the Peoples Temple cult, blindly following their leader Jim Jones, committed suicide by drinking cyanide-laced Kool-Aid.









8 Responses to “Spurgeon v. Osteen (Wanna Guess Who Wins?)”
I’ll agree that preachers are really messing us up with all their happy talk. I haven’t heard Osteen before so I won’t pick on him. Christians and people in general are starving for the straight talk for sure. We haven’t been to church regularly in years. I love Dr. D. James Kennedy because he gets into real life issues AND tells the Gospel, the whole Gospel, and nothing but… Activism is connecting the dots…putting us out there to restore the Kingdom. Don’t you think this is important? It’s kinda why we blog, right? Tell it like it is, brother!
cwv warrior ~ Jul 23, 2005 at 11:33 pm
Here would be my “straight talk” challenge to you, cwv: why haven’t you “been to church regularly in years”, and IMHO, the “whole Gospel” includes the fact that we need the body of Christ in order to live faithfully as Christ-followers! The New Testament never envisions a Christ-follower separated from the fellowship/accountability of a local church body; I cannot live as a Christian otherwise. I’d challenge you—in trying to “tell it like it is”!—to remedy this ASAP.
Byron ~ Jul 24, 2005 at 10:20 pm
I’ll agree Byron. A Christian who cuts himself off from the church is cutting himself off from a means of God’s grace. Why would we reject a gift of God? Church people occasionally drive me nuts, but I thank God for each one of them.
rev-ed ~ Jul 25, 2005 at 11:27 pm
I’ve been reading many criticisms of Osteen on various sites and I think the ones that criticize his preaching are well justified. He does very little (if any) true preaching of the Gospel. What a shame. But you know what else is a shame? People who are taking this opportunity to criticize other things like his mullet or his happy face. I think when that happens, it shows a little insight into the nature of judgmentalism. Mostly the critics have been right though. May God use this opportunity to show Joel where he needs to grow in order to be the ‘preacher’ that God truly desires him to be! Let’s continue to stick with the critiques that are meaningful.
- Mark M
Mark Merritt ~ Jul 26, 2005 at 12:33 pm
Yeah, you’re right, Mark; failing to stick to the issues (and there are several), and instead engaging in cheap-shotting, is sub-Christian. I HOPE that the issue is God showing Joel where he needs to grow; honestly, though, he ought not be preaching at all right now, not until/unless he gets a LOT of things straightened out, primarily his reluctance to preach the gospel!
Byron ~ Jul 26, 2005 at 2:56 pm
Building up self would be the best way to define his “preaching.”
Mark - cheap shots?! Maybe I missed it but, it sounds to me from what I read and heard from the comments (On Spencer’s article); the people who agree with Olsteen look to much on his outward appearance and don’t really listen to what he is saying and see if it lines up with God’s Word [which it obviously doesn't].
Billy ~ Jul 28, 2005 at 9:05 pm
Well, I suppose I will try to recover my reputation… Not that it matters much. The church is so split already, I’ll never please everyone!
I have plenty of wholesome accountability with the people around me. There are homeschoolers, prayer warriors, and my two teenage sons! Seriously, when we were in church, it seemed there was more of a pull off track than a push on. I think you know what i’m talkin.
Now that we have Bible curriculum, and access to Truth based materials, I’ve never been a more close follower of my Lord. I hate to think where the organized church would have left us if God hadn’t shown us His Truth from other sources. My son’s confirmation class was the last straw. He could have taught the darn thing. There is no accountability IN THE CHURCH!
That said, thank you for the honest concern. Since I didn’t find an email address, this is the short version. Too many pastors have let me down, even when I confronted them. Nicely, I might add.
cwv warrior ~ Jul 31, 2005 at 3:25 pm
CWV,
Don’t worry about your reputation here…it isn’t my intent to besmirch it in any way!
At the same time, while I very much understand your concerns /frustrations with the church, and its shortcomings, I cannot go with your final conclusion, not at all. I think that when a person takes that stance, while there are SOME areas of Christian living that can thrive, there are others that shrivel. I believe that a relational dynamic is essential to faithful Christian living, more than accountability (which, admittedly, can be gained outside of “church”).
I wonder how a person can effectively live out the “one anothers” outside the laboratory of committed relationships with believers (I’m sure you have some relationships—I’m not saying you can’t EVER do any of that outside of a church setting). I wonder what some church is missing because the gifts you have to offer are not being offered! I wonder how you can have involvement in the ordinances (some folks call them “sacraments”, but the old Baptist in me rebels against that!) outside of a local fellowship. I guess I wonder why there is an “either/or” at work here…you don’t have to toss the Bible curriculum or the Truth-based materials in order to be involved in a local church. I don’t see any warrant in the NT for a Christian who is not a vital part of a local church.
Look, there is no question that there are plenty of churches that are NOT healthy ones to be involved in…sure. But if memory serves, you’re a Pittsburgher, right? I can’t believe that there aren’t a few fellowships there that are worth finding and getting involved in—perhaps more for what you have to GIVE than for what you stand to GAIN. I mean, after all, it’s not about us, right?
I hear your frustration and raise you a disgust. But I can’t see how you can possibly be as well-rounded, in both the giving and gaining aspects of Christianity, as you’d be if you found a local church where the Word is taken seriously. I’d challenge you to get back on the horse and ride, and expand the blessing that you and your sons can GIVE by channeling your Christian faith through a local church. After all, the church, with all its warts, is still the only entity that Jesus promised will prevail over hell’s gates…
By the way, direct email access can be had at byronharvey@gmail.com.
Blessings,
Byron
Byron ~ Jul 31, 2005 at 6:53 pm